Monday, March 31, 2008

Who's to Blame?

In my opinion, the supplementary readings by Charles Bressler and Edward Said on Postcolonialism are the closest match with White Teeth as compared to the other texts and their supplements. The story is clearly a struggle between cultures, and as both essays make clear, also a matter of racism. We see innumerable amounts of examples where one character has an odd or uncomfortable feeling of another and some blatant instances of superiority of the British (especially in Archie's office) which cause what Postcolonialists would call the "alternity" of "Others", including Clara (Bressler, 236). An interesting point, as Said discusses, is on where to place the blame of such stereotypes. He suggests that it is within texts that people first learn these prejudices and because the "text [purports] to contain knowledge about something actual, [it] is not easily dismissed" (Said, 296). Perhaps then, would Said say, the only true way to know the reality of different races and cultures is through personal experience, an empiricist and scary (and perhaps incorrect) conclusion?

2 comments:

Barry said...

I just wanted to correct a misquote of Said. Instead place of a comma, there should really be an ellipsis:

"text [purports] to contain knowledge about something actual...[it] is not easily dismissed" (Said, 296).

Serafina said...

Well to truly learn about a culture you would certainly need to experience it first hand. Reading about it is the experience and views of one person, and if they have a stereotypical view about something, well certainly they will convey those view into their text (without even knowing it). Now I am not saying that Smith does this (because it is meant to be satirical in nature) but to some extent there is an unconscious representation of stereotypes whether it is meant to be there or not.